The Grand Escape
Resort chains · Head-to-head

Excellence vs Secrets

These two fight over the same traveler: adults-only, Mexico-or-Caribbean, upper-mid budget, food-motivated. Excellence is the focused family-owned operator whose handful of suite-only resorts are remarkably consistent; Secrets is Hyatt's sprawling adults-only fleet, where the range runs from spectacular to merely fine — with points as the sweetener.

Excellence ranking · Secrets ranking · How we score · Last reviewed July 2026

By the numbers

ExcellenceSecrets
Resorts in our catalog34
Average guest rating★ 4.9★ 4.4
Guest reviews analyzed58,8067,823
Nightly rates$500–$800+/night$500–$800+/night
Adults-only resortsAll adults-onlyAll adults-only
Five-star resorts3 of 34 of 4
WhereDominican Republic, Jamaica, MexicoAruba, Costa Rica, Dominican Republic
Overall score9.0/108.8/10
Beach score8.5/108.9/10
Food score8.5/108.4/10
Service score8.9/108.6/10
Rooms score8.8/108.7/10
Pools score9.0/108.9/10
Value score8.4/108.1/10
Romance score9.2/109.1/10
Nightlife score7.4/108.1/10
Wellness score8.8/108.8/10

Chain averages across the resorts in our catalog — individual properties vary, so tap into each ranking before you book.

Round by round

Consistency

Excellence — a short, tightly-run portfolio where the floor is high. Secrets' spread is wider in both directions; its best beat Excellence's best, its weakest don't come close.

Rooms

Excellence — all-suite properties with swim-outs as a standard category. Secrets matches it only in Preferred Club at newer builds.

Dining

Slight edge Excellence on depth-for-price; Secrets counters with reservation-free flexibility and 24-hour room service. Food-obsessed travelers do well at either.

Destination choice

Secrets — far more resorts and coastlines, including Pacific Mexico and Europe. Excellence is five-ish properties across three destinations.

Loyalty & points

Secrets — World of Hyatt earning and burning. Excellence has no equivalent currency.

The verdict

Booking blind, pick Excellence — the odds of a great week are simply higher across its portfolio. Booking carefully, a top-scoring Secrets property with points behind it is the better financial play. Since you're on a site built for booking carefully: compare the specific properties' scores, and let the points math break ties.

The properties to shortlist

Want it property-level? Put Excellence Playa Mujeres and Secrets Cap Cana Resort & Spa head-to-head — or open any two resorts in our resort comparator.

Frequently asked questions

Is Excellence part of Hyatt like Secrets?

No — Excellence is an independent, family-owned Spanish group (The Excellence Collection). Secrets belongs to Hyatt's Inclusive Collection, which is why it earns World of Hyatt points and Excellence doesn't.

More head-to-heads