It’s All Inclusive
Resort chains · Head-to-head

Excellence vs Secrets

These two fight over the same traveler: adults-only, Mexico-or-Caribbean, upper-mid budget, food-motivated. Excellence is the focused family-owned operator whose handful of suite-only resorts are remarkably consistent; Secrets is Hyatt's sprawling adults-only fleet, where the range runs from spectacular to merely fine, with points as the sweetener.

By the numbers

Excellence compared with Secrets
ExcellenceMeasureSecrets
6Resorts listed19
★ 4.9 (better)Average guest rating★ 4.4
106,345Guest reviews analyzed51,852
$182 to $387/night ppNightly rates$86 to $917/night pp
All adults-onlyAdults-only resortsAll adults-only
6 of 6Five-star resorts19 of 19
Dominican Republic, Jamaica, MexicoWhereAruba, Costa Rica, Dominican Republic, Jamaica (not open now), Mexico, Spain
8.8/10 (better)Overall score8.6/10
8.4/10Beach score8.5/10 (better)
8.4/10 (better)Food score8.2/10
8.8/10 (better)Service score8.5/10
8.8/10 (better)Rooms score8.5/10
8.9/10 (better)Pools score8.6/10
8.3/10 (better)Value score7.8/10
9.1/10 (better)Romance score8.9/10
7.3/10Nightlife score7.9/10 (better)
8.5/10Wellness score8.5/10

Chain averages, rounded to one decimal. A row is called only when the rounded figures differ, and the tally below counts those rows. Individual properties vary, so open each ranking before you book.

Who is counted: Secrets: 19 resorts listed, 3 not open now, 18 with an overall score. Averages use the resorts that have each figure. Chain rankings list only open, scored resorts, so their counts can be smaller.

Round by round

Round 1
Consistency

Excellence: a short, tightly-run portfolio where the floor is high. Secrets' spread is wider in both directions; its best beat Excellence's best, its weakest don't come close.

Round 2
Rooms

Excellence: all-suite properties with swim-outs as a standard category. Secrets matches it only in Preferred Club at newer builds.

Round 3
Dining

Slight edge Excellence on depth-for-price; Secrets counters with reservation-free flexibility and 24-hour room service. Food-obsessed travelers do well at either.

Round 4
Destination choice

Secrets: far more resorts and coastlines, including Pacific Mexico and Europe. Excellence is five-ish properties across three destinations.

Round 5
Loyalty & points

Secrets: World of Hyatt earning and burning. Excellence has no equivalent currency.

Of the 10 measures we call, Excellence leads on 8 and Secrets leads on 2.

Excellence Playa Mujeres pool area with blue water, palapa umbrellas, loungers, and beach with ocean beyond.
Excellence Playa Mujeres, Playa Mujeres, Mexico
The referee's call

The verdict

Clear win, Excellence

Booking blind, pick Excellence: the odds of a great week are simply higher across its portfolio. Booking carefully, a top-scoring Secrets property with points behind it is the better financial play. Since you're on a site built for booking carefully: compare the specific properties' scores, and let the points math break ties.