Elite Island Resorts vs Secrets

Elite Island Resorts and Secrets, side by side: every number below comes straight from our catalog — real guest ratings, our category scores, and the honest included-vs-extra research behind each resort.

Elite Island Resorts ranking · Secrets ranking · How we score

By the numbers

	Elite Island Resorts	Secrets
Resorts in our catalog	1	4
Average guest rating	★ 4.3	★ 4.4
Guest reviews analyzed	805	7,852
Nightly rates	—	$500–$800+/night
Adults-only resorts	All adults-only	All adults-only
Five-star resorts	0 of 1	4 of 4
Where	Barbados	Aruba, Costa Rica, Dominican Republic
Overall score	7.9/10	8.8/10
Beach score	8.2/10	8.9/10
Food score	7.6/10	8.4/10
Service score	8.0/10	8.6/10
Rooms score	7.3/10	8.7/10
Pools score	7.8/10	8.9/10
Value score	7.8/10	8.1/10
Romance score	8.0/10	9.1/10
Nightlife score	7.5/10	8.1/10
Wellness score	7.6/10	8.8/10

Chain averages across the resorts in our catalog — individual properties vary, so tap into each ranking before you book.

The properties to shortlist

Best of Elite Island Resorts

1.The Club Barbados Resort & Spa — · ★ 4.3

Full Elite Island Resorts ranking

Best of Secrets

Full Secrets ranking

Want it property-level? Put The Club Barbados Resort & Spa and Secrets Cap Cana Resort & Spa head-to-head — or open any two resorts in our resort comparator.

More head-to-heads

Sandals vs Beaches Sandals vs Excellence Sandals vs Zoëtry Sandals vs Secrets Sandals vs Couples Resorts Excellence vs Secrets Zoëtry vs Secrets Dreams vs Beaches RIU vs Iberostar