It’s All Inclusive
Resort chains · Head-to-head

Elite Island Resorts vs Secrets

Elite Island Resorts and Secrets, side by side: every number below is a chain average. Real guest ratings, our category scores, and the honest included-vs-extra research behind each resort.

By the numbers

Elite Island Resorts compared with Secrets
Elite Island ResortsMeasureSecrets
6Resorts listed19
★ 4.4Average guest rating★ 4.4
4,684Guest reviews analyzed51,852
$232 to $877/night ppNightly rates$86 to $917/night pp
5 of 6Adults-only resortsAll adults-only
2 of 6Five-star resorts19 of 19 (better)
Antigua, BarbadosWhereAruba, Costa Rica, Dominican Republic, Jamaica (not open now), Mexico, Spain
8.4/10Overall score8.6/10 (better)
8.6/10 (better)Beach score8.5/10
8.2/10Food score8.2/10
8.4/10Service score8.5/10 (better)
8.1/10Rooms score8.5/10 (better)
8.3/10Pools score8.6/10 (better)
7.9/10 (better)Value score7.8/10
8.9/10Romance score8.9/10
7.5/10Nightlife score7.9/10 (better)
8.2/10Wellness score8.5/10 (better)

Chain averages, rounded to one decimal. A row is called only when the rounded figures differ, and the tally below counts those rows. Individual properties vary, so open each ranking before you book.

Who is counted: Secrets: 19 resorts listed, 3 not open now, 18 with an overall score. Averages use the resorts that have each figure. Chain rankings list only open, scored resorts, so their counts can be smaller.