Head to head

Mahekal Beach ResortvsVOI Marsa Siclà Essentia

Share as a post (opens in a new tab)
Mahekal Beach Resort
Mahekal Beach Resort
Playa del Carmen, Mexico
Five-Star·4.4
VOI Marsa Siclà Essentia
VOI Marsa Siclà Essentia
Four-Star·4.6

Scores at a Glance

Mahekal Beach ResortVOI Marsa Siclà Essentia
Overall
8.7
8.4
Beach
8.6
8.5
Food
8.6
8.1
Service
8.8
8.4
Rooms
8.4
8.2
Luxury
8.1
·
Value
8.0
·
Romance
8.5
·
Scores out of 10 · higher is better

Quick Stats

Mahekal Beach ResortMeasureVOI Marsa Siclà Essentia
(better)8.7Overall Score8.4
(better)5-starStar Rating4-star
4.4 (4,730)Google Rating4.6 (1,019) (better)
From $91Price / Night (pp)Rates TBD
NoAdults OnlyNo
Kids' ClubYes
OceanfrontBeachfrontNear coast
BoutiqueResort SizeMid-size
(better)45 minAirport Transfer85 min

All Scores

Mahekal Beach ResortMeasureVOI Marsa Siclà Essentia
(better)8.6Beach8.5
(better)8.6Food8.1
(better)8.8Service8.4
(better)8.4Rooms8.2
(better)8.8Pools8.2
8.1Luxury
8.0Value
(better)8.4Family8.3
8.5Romance
7.8Nightlife
7.7Quiet8.8 (better)
8.2Adventure
8.5Wellness
7.0Remote work
Accessibility8.5

Of the 11 measures we call, Mahekal Beach Resort leads on 9 and VOI Marsa Siclà Essentia leads on 2.

Vibes

Mahekal Beach ResortMeasureVOI Marsa Siclà Essentia
YesAdventure
YesQuietYes
YesRomance

Activities

Mahekal Beach ResortMeasureVOI Marsa Siclà Essentia
YesSpaYes
YesWater sportsYes
YesDiving
KidsYes

Mahekal Beach Resort

  • Bohemian eco-resort on the beach
  • Thatched-roof bungalows
  • Cenote excursions included
  • Locally sourced organic dining

VOI Marsa Siclà Essentia

  • 2 restaurants & bars
  • Full-service spa
  • 85 min from CTA

Pros · Mahekal Beach Resort

  • Direct beachfront setting in central Playa del Carmen.
  • Easy walking access to Fifth Avenue and downtown Playa del Carmen.
  • Boutique-style grounds with gardens, palapa-style rooms, and a relaxed Mexican-Caribbean feel.
  • Four pools and a strong beachfront pool atmosphere.
  • Good fit for couples, families, and travelers who want a resort plus town access.

Pros · VOI Marsa Siclà Essentia

  • Official room information is transparent.
  • Family-friendly with a Kids Club for ages 3–8.
  • Good sandy beach access in the Sampieri area.

Cons · Mahekal Beach Resort

  • Beach conditions can vary with seaweed and seasonal coastal conditions.
  • Not adults-only and not a quiet secluded escape.
  • Some guests may find the rustic-bohemian room style less luxurious than newer resorts.
  • All-inclusive value depends on whether guests plan to dine mostly on property or explore Playa del Carmen restaurants.

Cons · VOI Marsa Siclà Essentia

  • Not beachfront.
  • All-inclusive is optional and has exclusions.
  • Remote setting makes a car or planned transfers useful.
View Mahekal Beach ResortCheck Rates at Mahekal Beach Resort (opens in a new tab)
View VOI Marsa Siclà EssentiaCheck Rates at VOI Marsa Siclà Essentia (opens in a new tab)
Keep exploring

Similar resorts

Akumal Bay Beach & Wellness Resort
Akumal Bay Beach & Wellness Resort
Mexico · 5-star
Allegro Cozumel - All Inclusive
Allegro Cozumel - All Inclusive
Mexico · 4-star
ATELIER Playa Mujeres
ATELIER Playa Mujeres
Mexico · 5-star
Bahia Principe Explore Akumal
Bahia Principe Explore Akumal
Mexico · 5-star
Barceló Maya Colonial - All Inclusive
Barceló Maya Colonial - All Inclusive
Mexico · 5-star
Barceló Maya Grand Resort
Barceló Maya Grand Resort
Mexico · 5-star
Barceló Maya Palace - All Inclusive
Barceló Maya Palace - All Inclusive
Mexico · 5-star
Barceló Maya Riviera - All Inclusive Adults Only
Barceló Maya Riviera - All Inclusive Adults Only
Mexico · 5-star
Barceló Maya Tropical
Barceló Maya Tropical
Mexico · 5-star
Barceló Puerto Vallarta
Barceló Puerto Vallarta
Mexico · 5-star
Beach Palace
Beach Palace
Mexico · 4-star
CDSHotels Terrasini - Città del Mare
CDSHotels Terrasini - Città del Mare
Italy · 4-star
Not these two?

Run another comparison