Head to head
Barceló Maya Palace - All InclusivevsPlaya Garden Selection Hotel & Spa
Share as a post ↗
Scores at a Glance
Barceló Maya Palace - All InclusivePlaya Garden Selection Hotel & Spa
Overall
8.8
8.1
Beach
8.6
9.0
Food
8.2
7.8
Service
8.5
8.0
Rooms
8.8
7.9
Luxury
8.5
—
Value
8.3
7.8
Scores out of 10 — higher is better
Quick Stats
8.8
Overall Score
8.1
5-star
Star Rating
4-star
4.9 (51,250)
Google Rating
4.7 (3,807)
From $119
Price / Night (pp)
Rates TBD
No
Adults Only
No
Yes
Kids' Club
Yes
Near coast
Beachfront
Near coast
Mid-size
Resort Size
Mid-size
—
Airport Transfer
55 min
All Scores
8.6
Beach
9.0
8.2
Food
7.8
8.5
Service
8.0
8.8
Rooms
7.9
9.0
Pools
8.0
8.5
Luxury
—
8.3
Value
7.8
9.2
Family
8.5
7.4
Quiet
—
7.7
Accessibility
—
Vibes
Yes
Quiet
—
Activities
Yes
Spa
Yes
Yes
Water sports
Yes
Yes
Kids
Yes
Barceló Maya Palace - All Inclusive
- 3 pools
- 6 restaurants & bars
- Full-service spa
Playa Garden Selection Hotel & Spa
- 3 pools
- 2 restaurants & bars
- Full-service spa
- 55 min from PMI
Pros — Barceló Maya Palace - All Inclusive
- All-suite room inventory.
- Strong review-platform ratings for a large family all-inclusive.
- Three pools, children's water park and broad sister-resort access.
Pros — Playa Garden Selection Hotel & Spa
- Excellent beach location
- Good family fit
- Apartment-style room inventory
- Optional all-inclusive board
Cons — Barceló Maya Palace - All Inclusive
- Large resort scale creates walking-distance and crowding tradeoffs.
- Restaurant reservations can be a friction point.
- Beach entry is not universally smooth.
Cons — Playa Garden Selection Hotel & Spa
- Not all dining appears fully included
- Some extras can surprise guests
- No strong resort-specific Reddit source found
- Exact kids-club ages need manual confirmation