It’s All Inclusive
Head to head

Excellence Oyster BayvsSecrets St. James Montego Bay

Excellence Oyster Bay
Excellence Oyster Bay
Five-Star·★ 4.9·Adults Only
Secrets St. James Montego Bay
Secrets St. James Montego Bay
Five-Star·★ 4.3·Adults Only

Scores at a Glance

Excellence Oyster BaySecrets St. James Montego Bay
Overall
8.9
8.2
Beach
9.1
8.4
Food
8.6
8.0
Service
8.5
7.8
Rooms
9.1
7.8
Value
8.4
·
Romance
9.3
8.5
Scores out of 10 · higher is better

Quick Stats

Excellence Oyster BayMeasureSecrets St. James Montego Bay
(better)8.9Overall Score8.2
5-starStar Rating5-star
(better)4.9 (17,312)Google Rating4.3 (3,248)
From $295Price / Night (pp)Rates TBD
YesAdults OnlyYes
Not applicableKids' ClubNot applicable
Near coastBeachfrontNear coast
Mid-sizeResort SizeMid-size
39 minAirport Transfer15 min (better)

Excellence Oyster Bay

Kids' club & childcare
Not applicable: adults only
Room service
Included. 24-hour room service
Dining reservations
Reservations required: Spice (Teppanyaki stations only). Confirmed walk-in: The Kitchen Table, Chez Isabelle, The Grill, The Lobster House, Oregano, Magna. Other reservation rules are unverified; confirm before booking. Spice: Teppanyaki stations require reservations; ordinary dinner seating is walk-in. The Lobster House: The supplier lists an annual lobster closed season from April 1 through June 30; this does not establish closure of the whole restaurant. Magna: Excellence Club guests only. Zenith: Excellence Club guests only. 8 à-la-carte dinner venues plus buffet, jerk house and takeaway wood-oven pizza; only the hibachi tables need booking Magna is for Excellence Club guests only. Zenith is also for Excellence Club guests only. The official fact sheet lists 11 bars; restaurant totals vary by section and remain qualified.
Single accommodation capacity
Largest confirmed capacity: 2 people in one accommodation. Junior Suite; Beachfront House Suite with Plunge Pool. Adult limit unverified.
See supplier details at Excellence Oyster Bay

Secrets St. James Montego Bay

Kids' club & childcare
Not applicable: adults only
Room service
Included. Official materials state 24-hour room service/private in-suite dining is included.
Dining reservations
Restaurant reservation rules are unverified; confirm before booking. Portofino: A wine cellar is listed; its private-dining pricing and booking rules remain unverified. Hyatt dining page shows 20 dining and drink results and says reservations are never required; guests have free-flow access to Secrets Wild Orchid. The December 2025 guide describes a shared dining inventory across the Promenade, St. James and Wild Orchid; ten is not an independently confirmed count of restaurants physically within St. James. The standard no-reservation statement does not cover the separately described romantic/private dinner: advance concierge reservation is required, with variable cost and possible package conditions. Exact prices are unverified.
Single accommodation capacity
Largest confirmed capacity: 3 people in one accommodation. Junior Suite Garden View; Junior Suite Ocean View; Junior Suite Ocean Front; 3 more categories at this capacity. Adult limit unverified.
See supplier details at Secrets St. James Montego Bay

Excellence Oyster Bay

Highlights

  • Adults-only all-inclusive
  • 4 pools
  • 10 places to eat
  • Full-service spa
  • Butler service
  • 39 min from MBJ

Why choose it

  • Beautiful private peninsula setting.
  • Strong adults-only romance profile.
  • Beach House and villa categories are a major differentiator.
  • Multiple restaurants and club-level areas.
  • Good fit for honeymooners and couples seeking a polished all-inclusive.

Keep in mind

  • Service can feel slow or inconsistent in some guest reports.
  • Not walkable to town or local restaurants.
  • Entertainment is more relaxed than high-energy.
  • Premium room categories can be expensive.

Secrets St. James Montego Bay

Highlights

  • Adults-only all-inclusive
  • Full-service spa
  • Butler service
  • Swim-up suites
  • 15 min from MBJ

Why choose it

  • Adults-only Unlimited-Luxury inclusions.
  • Large shared dining and bar footprint.
  • Close to MBJ airport.
  • Good romance and nightlife balance.

Keep in mind

  • Temporarily closed following Hurricane Melissa. Hyatt currently expects reopening in Q1 2027; an exact reopening date is not confirmed.
  • Some areas are described as dated in recent guest discussions.
  • Preferred Club and Breathless access rules can be confusing.

All Scores

Excellence Oyster BayMeasureSecrets St. James Montego Bay
(better)9.1Beach8.4
(better)8.6Food8.0
(better)8.5Service7.8
(better)9.1Rooms7.8
(better)8.9Pools8.0
8.4Value–
(better)9.3Romance8.5
–Nightlife8.2
(better)8.7Quiet7.7
8.0Remote work–

Of the 10 measures we call, Excellence Oyster Bay leads on 9 and Secrets St. James Montego Bay leads on 1.

Vibes

Excellence Oyster BayMeasureSecrets St. James Montego Bay
YesRomanceYes
YesQuietYes
–LivelyYes

Activities

Excellence Oyster BayMeasureSecrets St. James Montego Bay
YesSpaYes
YesWater sportsYes
–NightlifeYes
Keep exploring

Similar resorts

Not these two?

Run another comparison