Head to head
Excellence Oyster BayvsSecrets St. James Montego Bay
Share as a post (opens in a new tab)
Scores at a Glance
Excellence Oyster BaySecrets St. James Montego Bay
Overall
8.9
8.2
Beach
9.1
8.4
Food
8.6
8.0
Service
8.5
7.8
Rooms
9.1
7.8
Value
8.4
·
Romance
9.3
8.5
Scores out of 10 · higher is better
Quick Stats
| Excellence Oyster Bay | Measure | Secrets St. James Montego Bay |
|---|---|---|
| (better)8.9 | Overall Score | 8.2 |
| 5-star | Star Rating | 5-star |
| (better)4.9 (17,062) | Google Rating | 4.3 (3,247) |
| From $259 | Price / Night (pp) | Rates TBD |
| Yes | Adults Only | Yes |
| – | Kids' Club | – |
| Near coast | Beachfront | Near coast |
| Mid-size | Resort Size | Mid-size |
| 39 min | Airport Transfer | 15 min (better) |
All Scores
| Excellence Oyster Bay | Measure | Secrets St. James Montego Bay |
|---|---|---|
| (better)9.1 | Beach | 8.4 |
| (better)8.6 | Food | 8.0 |
| (better)8.5 | Service | 7.8 |
| (better)9.1 | Rooms | 7.8 |
| (better)8.9 | Pools | 8.0 |
| 8.4 | Value | – |
| (better)9.3 | Romance | 8.5 |
| – | Nightlife | 8.2 |
| (better)8.7 | Quiet | 7.7 |
| 8.0 | Remote work | – |
Of the 10 measures we call, Excellence Oyster Bay leads on 9 and Secrets St. James Montego Bay leads on 1.
Vibes
| Excellence Oyster Bay | Measure | Secrets St. James Montego Bay |
|---|---|---|
| Yes | Romance | Yes |
| Yes | Quiet | Yes |
| – | Lively | Yes |
Activities
| Excellence Oyster Bay | Measure | Secrets St. James Montego Bay |
|---|---|---|
| Yes | Spa | Yes |
| Yes | Water sports | Yes |
| – | Nightlife | Yes |
Excellence Oyster Bay
- Adults-only all-inclusive
- 4 pools
- 10 restaurants & bars
- Full-service spa
- Butler service
- 39 min from MBJ
Secrets St. James Montego Bay
- Adults-only all-inclusive
- Full-service spa
- Butler service
- Swim-up suites
- 15 min from MBJ
Pros · Excellence Oyster Bay
- Beautiful private peninsula setting.
- Strong adults-only romance profile.
- Beach House and villa categories are a major differentiator.
- Multiple restaurants and club-level areas.
- Good fit for honeymooners and couples seeking a polished all-inclusive.
Pros · Secrets St. James Montego Bay
- Adults-only Unlimited-Luxury inclusions.
- Large shared dining and bar footprint.
- Close to MBJ airport.
- Good romance and nightlife balance.
Cons · Excellence Oyster Bay
- Service can feel slow or inconsistent in some guest reports.
- Not walkable to town or local restaurants.
- Entertainment is more relaxed than high-energy.
- Premium room categories can be expensive.
Cons · Secrets St. James Montego Bay
- Current operating status needs manual confirmation.
- Some areas are described as dated in recent guest discussions.
- Preferred Club and Breathless access rules can be confusing.
Keep exploring
Similar resorts
Not these two?