Head to head

Pineapple Beach Club AntiguavsSt. James's Club & Villas

Pineapple Beach Club Antigua

Four-Star·★ 4.3·Adults Only

St. James's Club & Villas

Four-Star·★ 4.2

Scores at a Glance

Pineapple Beach Club AntiguaSt. James's Club & Villas

Overall

8.4

7.9

Beach

8.9

8.4

Food

8.0

7.4

Service

8.6

7.7

Rooms

7.7

7.2

Value

8.0

7.5

Romance

8.6

8.4

7.9

Overall

8.9

8.4

Beach

8.0

7.4

Food

8.6

7.7

Service

7.7

7.2

Rooms

8.0

7.5

Value

8.6

—

Romance

Scores out of 10 · higher is better

Quick Stats

Pineapple Beach Club Antigua	Measure	St. James's Club & Villas
(better)8.4	Overall Score	7.9
4-star	Star Rating	4-star
(better)4.3 (1,160)	Google Rating	4.2 (932)
From $274	Price / Night (pp)	From $269 (better)
Yes	Adults Only	No
Not applicable	Kids' Club	Listed
Near coast	Beachfront	Near coast
Mid-size	Resort Size	Mid-size
42 min	Airport Transfer	30 min (better)

Pineapple Beach Club Antigua

Kids' club & childcare: Not applicable: adults only
Room service: Unverified
Dining reservations: Restaurant reservation rules are unverified; confirm before booking.
Single accommodation capacity: Capacity unverified; confirm the exact category before booking.

See supplier details at Pineapple Beach Club Antigua

St. James's Club & Villas

Kids' club & childcare: Kids’ club listed: 4–11. Official FAQ states kids club is for potty-trained children ages 4 to 11; babysitting and evening kids club activities are currently unavailable. Confirm supervision and drop-off rules.
Room service: Available with limits. Official FAQ states room service is available from 5:00 p.m. to 10:00 p.m.
Dining reservations: Restaurant reservation rules are unverified; confirm before booking.
Single accommodation capacity: Largest confirmed capacity: 7 people in one accommodation. Three-Bedroom Villa. Adult limit unverified.

See supplier details at St. James's Club & Villas

Pineapple Beach Club Antigua

Highlights

Adults-only all-inclusive
3 pools
5 places to eat
Full-service spa
42 min from ANU

Why choose it

Adults-only all-inclusive model.
Quarter-mile beachfront setting.
Included paddleboards, kayaks, Hobie Cats and snorkeling gear.
Six pickleball courts and two tennis courts.

Keep in mind

One featured steakhouse carries a surcharge.
Some room categories feel older.
Premium beverage details need confirmation.

St. James's Club & Villas

Highlights

6 pools
5 places to eat
Full-service spa
30 min from ANU

Why choose it

Two beaches on a secluded peninsula.
Six pools and a children's pool.
Large two- and three-bedroom villas.
Kids club for ages 4 to 11 and strong water-sports base.

Keep in mind

Mandatory local resort fee and tourism levy.
Piccolo Mondo carries a surcharge.
Some villas and bathrooms receive dated-condition complaints.

All Scores

Pineapple Beach Club Antigua	Measure	St. James's Club & Villas
(better)8.9	Beach	8.4
(better)8.0	Food	7.4
(better)8.6	Service	7.7
(better)7.7	Rooms	7.2
8.0	Pools	8.4 (better)
(better)8.0	Value	7.5
–	Family	8.5
8.6	Romance	–
(better)8.0	Quiet	7.6
–	Remote work	6.8